Rent vs Buy Calculator
This rent-versus-buy calculator compares constant rent with a cash or fixed-rate mortgage purchase followed by a sale. It includes ownership costs, transaction charges and sale equity, but excludes investment returns and tax benefits.
By Dr. Hassan Khames EliwaLast updated
Result
Positive favors buying within this cost model; investment returns and tax benefits excluded.
- Total rent
- $60,000.00
- Net ownership cost after sale
- $10,000.00
- Net sale proceeds
- $97,000.00
- Rent$60.0k
- Ownership$10.0k
How it works
Keep cash movement and equity together
For an all-cash purchase, the buying side begins with the price plus purchase costs. For mortgage financing, it begins with the down payment and purchase costs, then adds the payments made before sale. The loan uses month-end payments and nominal annual interest divided by twelve. The remaining mortgage balance is deducted from net sale proceeds, so principal is not counted twice as an expense. Annual carrying costs are entered as a percentage of the original price and remain constant in dollars. Include property tax, insurance, routine maintenance and association charges in that combined allowance. The model does not silently add any of them later.
Resale value equals the original price compounded by your annual appreciation assumption for the holding period. Sale costs are a percentage of that ending value. Net sale proceeds are subtracted from the purchase outlay and cumulative carrying costs to obtain net ownership cost. A negative ownership cost means modeled sale proceeds exceeded those outlays; it does not mean ownership generated spendable monthly income.
Rent cost is monthly rent multiplied by the holding period in months. It assumes no rent increases, deposit loss, renters insurance or relocation expenses. Add material differences to your own comparison rather than assuming they cancel. The headline subtracts ownership cost from rent cost, so a positive number favors buying within this narrow scenario.
The missing opportunity cost matters
An all-cash buyer commits capital that a renter might retain or invest. This calculator assigns no return to that alternative use and does not discount future proceeds. It therefore cannot establish which choice creates more terminal wealth. Strong appreciation can make buying look especially attractive, but that result depends directly on an uncertain input.
Select mortgage financing to compare payments and remaining debt at the same sale horizon. Use the mortgage calculator as a payment cross-check. Keep mortgage installments out of the carrying-cost field: they are calculated separately. After the loan term ends, payments stop while operating costs continue. A wealth comparison also needs the renter’s retained capital and either household’s investment returns, which are not modeled here.
Worked example
Example one: no price growth
Consider a $100,000 cash purchase or rent of $1,000 per month for five years. Assume zero appreciation, annual carrying costs of 1% of original price, purchase costs of 2% and sale costs of 3%. Total rent is $60,000.00. Net sale proceeds are $97,000.00, and net ownership cost after sale is $10,000.00.
The headline rent cost minus ownership cost is $50,000.00. That is an undiscounted difference in the included housing costs, not a guaranteed return from buying. The cash buyer had to supply the purchase capital at the beginning, while the renter did not. Omitting that distinction from a real decision would overstate what this simple comparison proves.
Example two: a rising resale assumption
Keep the $100,000 price, $1,000 monthly rent, 1% carrying allowance, 2% purchase costs and 3% sale costs. Change the holding period to one year and appreciation to 10%. Total rent is $12,000.00 and net sale proceeds are $106,700.00. Net ownership cost becomes −$3,700.00, producing a headline difference of $15,700.00.
The negative ownership cost is a consequence of the assumed resale gain exceeding the modeled charges. It is not a forecast, and selling costs still apply to the higher ending value. Run flat-price and declining-price cases before relying on appreciation to justify a purchase.
Expert tips
Common mistakes
- Treating appreciation as a promised return. A smooth annual percentage is a scenario device; actual sale prices, marketing periods and transaction conditions can be unfavorable precisely when you need to move.
- Ignoring the cash that renting leaves available. A fuller wealth comparison needs an explicit investment-return assumption, taxes on that return and consistent treatment of the timing of cash flows.
- Reading a negative ownership cost as proof the home is affordable. The purchase still requires cash at closing, and repairs or other carrying costs must be funded before the eventual sale.
For education, not financial advice. Results are estimates based on the inputs you give. Lenders, tax authorities and advisers may use different rules, fees and rounding. Check the numbers with a qualified professional before you commit to anything.
Frequently asked questions
Does this include a mortgage?
Yes. Select fixed-rate mortgage financing and enter the deposit, nominal annual rate and whole-year term. Payments and the balance at sale are calculated separately from recurring ownership costs.
Is property tax included?
Only if you include it in the annual ownership-cost percentage. Combine the recurring costs relevant to the property rather than assuming a hidden allowance has been added.
Can ownership cost be negative?
Yes. Under sufficiently strong appreciation, modeled net sale proceeds can exceed purchase and carrying outlays. That is an assumption-dependent capital gain, not recurring income.
Are rent increases modeled?
No. Rent remains constant throughout the holding period. If you expect significant increases, compare several constant-rent scenarios or use a separate year-by-year cash-flow analysis.
Does the larger headline identify the best choice?
It identifies the cheaper included cost stream under your entries. Opportunity cost, taxes on gains, flexibility and property-specific risks remain outside that headline.
Related calculators
Related guides
FinancialRent or buy: the numbers that actually decide itCompare housing cash costs, mortgage balances and sale equity over a realistic holding period, not just monthly payments.14 November 2026 · 8 min read
FinancialHow mortgage amortization really worksEarly payments are mostly interest because the balance is still large—not because the lender charges all the interest upfront.14 November 2026 · 7 min read
FinancialCompound interest: three real savings scenariosThree practical savings examples show what comes from your deposits, what comes from growth, and which assumptions deserve scrutiny.14 November 2026 · 7 min readAbout the author
Dr. Hassan Khames Eliwa holds a PhD in Construction & Built Environment and has more than 20 years of international project controls experience. He is Director of Eliwa Project Controls Limited in Auckland and founder of PMMilestone.org and PMMilestone.com.
Buy me a coffee