Refinance Calculator
This refinance calculator compares a remaining fixed-rate loan with a replacement loan on the same principal balance. It shows the payment change, upfront cash-cost recovery and undiscounted lifetime payments, keeping a lower installment separate from genuine cost savings.
By Dr. Hassan Khames EliwaLast updated
Result
- Current monthly principal and interest
- $507.51
- Monthly payment reduction
- $7.51
- Simple cash-cost break-even months
- 0
- Current remaining total payments
- $1,015.02
- New total payments plus cash costs
- $1,000.00
- Undiscounted lifetime savings
- $15.02
How it works
Compare from today, not from origination
The current loan begins with its outstanding balance and remaining payment count. Interest already paid is a sunk cost and does not enter the decision. The replacement loan starts with that same principal, a new nominal annual rate and a new payment count. Both loans use equal month-end principal-and-interest installments and monthly interest accrual.
Closing costs are paid in cash at the start. They are not added to the new principal in this version. Include genuine incremental transaction charges, but distinguish them from refundable escrow balances and prepaid expenses you would incur under either choice. If costs are financed, this comparison is not sufficient: the replacement loan needs a larger opening balance.
Read both savings measures
Monthly payment reduction equals the current installment minus the new installment. Simple break-even divides upfront costs by that reduction and rounds upward to a whole payment month. It is shown only when recovery occurs while both schedules are still making payments. Zero cash costs produce immediate cost recovery, not a claim that the refinance is beneficial.
Lifetime savings compare all remaining current installments against all new installments plus cash closing costs. This is an undiscounted comparison over potentially different terms. It does not measure the value of a sale at an intermediate date, because that requires comparing the outstanding balances at the same horizon.
A longer replacement term can produce attractive monthly relief and a worse lifetime outcome. Even when both measures are positive, check prepayment penalties, time remaining in the property and your ability to fund costs without expensive short-term borrowing. Taxes, insurance, points deducted for tax purposes and investment returns on cash are outside this model.
Worked example
Example one: remove the remaining interest
A $1,000 balance has two payments left at a 12% nominal annual rate. Replace it with a zero-rate loan over the same two months and no closing costs. The current monthly payment is $507.51 and the new payment is $500.00, a reduction of $7.51. Simple cash-cost break-even is 0 months.
Remaining payments on the existing loan total $1,015.02. New payments plus cash costs total $1,000.00, giving undiscounted lifetime savings of $15.02. Because the terms match and costs are absent, the difference comes entirely from removing interest. Displayed installments are rounded, while totals use full precision.
Example two: relief that costs more overall
Take a $1,200 balance at zero interest with 12 months remaining. Refinance at zero interest over 24 months, paying $120 in cash costs. The current payment is $100.00 and the new payment is $50.00, giving $50.00 of monthly payment reduction. Simple cash-cost recovery takes 3 months.
Yet remaining current payments total $1,200.00, while new payments plus costs total $1,320.00. Lifetime savings are −$120.00. The early payment reduction is a deferral of principal, not an interest saving. Once the original loan would have ended, the replacement still requires installments. This is why a quick cash-flow break-even is not a complete economic verdict.
Expert tips
Common mistakes
- Counting prior interest as money the refinance must recover. The decision concerns future cash flows; historical financing costs do not change when you choose a replacement loan today.
- Calling escrow funding a permanent refinancing fee without checking refunds and timing. Temporary cash requirements matter for liquidity, but they are not always incremental lifetime costs.
- Treating the break-even month as an investment return. The simple calculation ignores discounting, differing balances and cash flows after either schedule ends; use it as a screening measure only.
For education, not financial advice. Results are estimates based on the inputs you give. Lenders, tax authorities and advisers may use different rules, fees and rounding. Check the numbers with a qualified professional before you commit to anything.
Frequently asked questions
Are closing costs financed here?
No. They are paid in cash at inception. Rolling them into the loan changes principal and interest, which requires a different replacement-balance calculation.
Can a lower payment be more expensive?
Yes. Extending repayment can defer principal and add costs even with a lower rate. Review lifetime payments alongside the monthly reduction.
Why might break-even be unavailable?
Positive upfront costs cannot be recovered through payment reduction if there is no reduction, or if the simple recovery point falls beyond the period when both loans have payments.
Does this account for selling early?
No. An early-sale comparison must include each outstanding balance at the sale date. Lifetime totals cannot substitute for that matched-horizon analysis.
Should I overpay instead?
The mortgage payoff calculator tests keeping the current loan and adding principal each month. Compare flexibility, transaction charges and cash reserves before choosing either route.
Related calculators
Related guides
FinancialRent or buy: the numbers that actually decide itCompare housing cash costs, mortgage balances and sale equity over a realistic holding period, not just monthly payments.14 November 2026 · 8 min read
FinancialHow mortgage amortization really worksEarly payments are mostly interest because the balance is still large—not because the lender charges all the interest upfront.14 November 2026 · 7 min read
FinancialCompound interest: three real savings scenariosThree practical savings examples show what comes from your deposits, what comes from growth, and which assumptions deserve scrutiny.14 November 2026 · 7 min readSources and standards
About the author
Dr. Hassan Khames Eliwa holds a PhD in Construction & Built Environment and has more than 20 years of international project controls experience. He is Director of Eliwa Project Controls Limited in Auckland and founder of PMMilestone.org and PMMilestone.com.
Buy me a coffee